The automotive world is abuzz with innovations. Two main players leading the charge towards a sustainable future are hydrogen fuel cell vehicles (FCVs) and electric vehicles (EVs). But as we shift gears into this new era, which technology promises a smoother ride for both the consumer and the planet?

Are Hydrogen or Electric Cars Better?

The Mechanics of Movement

At their core, both types of vehicles aim to diminish the dependency on fossil fuels. However, their methodologies differ:

  • Hydrogen fuel cell vehicles (FCVs): These cars run on hydrogen gas. The gas, stored in high-pressure tanks, feeds into fuel cells which then produce electricity. This electricity powers the car’s motor.
  • Electric vehicles (EVs): An EV is powered by an onboard battery pack. When charged, this battery provides electricity to the motor, propelling the vehicle forward.

What are the Advantages?

The benefits of both hydrogen fuel cell vehicles and electric vehicles are multifaceted. Let’s dive a bit deeper into the compelling advantages each offers.

Hydrogen Fuel Cell Vehicles (FCVs)

  • Refuelling speed: The efficiency of refuelling a FCV is undeniably one of its major selling points. The time it takes to fill up is akin to what we’re used to with petrol or diesel vehicles. For those on a tight schedule or often travelling longer distances, this convenience cannot be overstated.
  • Range: FCVs shine when it comes to range. For those who experience ‘range anxiety’ with some electric vehicles, FCVs can often provide peace of mind. With a single tank of hydrogen, many FCVs can cover distances that rival or even surpass traditional vehicles, reducing the need to constantly plan for the next stop.
  • Lighter weight: Hydrogen tanks, although robust, often result in a lighter overall vehicle weight compared to EVs with large battery packs. This can provide benefits in terms of vehicle performance and efficiency.
  • Clean emission: The primary by-product of the hydrogen fuel cell process is water. This means that during operation, an FCV has zero harmful emissions, making it an environmentally friendly choice on the road.

Electric Vehicles (EVs)

  • Infrastructure: The proliferation of EV charging points in the UK and many parts of the world is a testament to their increasing popularity. From city centres to motorway services, it’s becoming ever easier to find a charging spot, making the EV experience more user-friendly by the day.
  • Emissions: While the production and disposal of batteries come with their own set of environmental challenges, EVs win big when it comes to tailpipe emissions. They simply don’t have any. This contributes to cleaner urban air and is a step towards combatting urban pollution.
  • Running costs: Not only is electricity generally cheaper than hydrogen, but EVs also boast fewer moving parts than their internal combustion engine (ICE) counterparts. This often translates to lower maintenance costs over the lifespan of the vehicle.
  • Quiet operation: One often overlooked advantage of EVs is their quiet operation. This reduction in noise pollution is particularly noticeable and appreciated in urban settings, creating a calmer and more peaceful environment.
  • Instant torque: From a driver’s perspective, the instant torque provided by an electric motor means that EVs can offer fast and responsive acceleration, enhancing the driving experience.

Drawbacks to Consider

Nothing is without its challenges, and these vehicles are no exception.

Hydrogen Fuel Cell Vehicles

  • Infrastructure hurdles: While hydrogen stations are growing in number, they’re still far outnumbered by EV charging points. This can make planning long journeys a bit more complicated.
  • Production concerns: Current hydrogen production predominantly relies on natural gas, which still leaves a carbon footprint. However, if green hydrogen production (using renewable energy sources) becomes the norm, this issue can be mitigated.

Electric Vehicles

  • Charging time: Charging an EV, especially from a regular plug, takes considerably longer compared to refuelling an FCV.
  • Battery lifespan: Over time, an EV’s battery can degrade, which may result in reduced range of performance. It’s a concern that manufacturers are continuously working on.

Comparing the Costs

When we look at the financial aspect of the debate, there are a couple of main points to consider:

  • Purchase price: Historically, EVs held the advantage here with various grants and incentives making them more affordable. FCVs, while becoming more competitive, still carry a higher price tag on average.
  • Running costs: Electricity, in most cases, proves cheaper than hydrogen. Factor in the longevity of an EV battery, though, and potential replacement costs, and the picture becomes a bit murkier.

Environmental Impacts

  • Hydrogen: While FCVs emit only water from their tailpipes, the production of hydrogen can be carbon-intensive unless derived from green methods.
  • Electricity: The cleanliness of an EV depends heavily on the source of its electricity. If powered by renewable sources, it’s a clear win for the environment. But reliance on fossil fuel-generated electricity dims this advantage.

What Does the Future Hold?

The future of transportation, while steering towards sustainability, is still evolving. Both hydrogen and electric vehicles are contending to define the next era.

Electric Vehicles

  • Infrastructure momentum: The current momentum behind EV infrastructure, particularly in developed nations, is hard to deny. As more cities introduce low-emission zones and with governmental incentives in play, there’s a massive push for expanding the network of charging stations.
  • Technological innovations: Battery technology is advancing at a rapid pace. As researchers look towards solid-state batteries and other novel technologies, we can expect EVs with longer ranges, faster charging times, and possibly, lower costs.
  • Mainstream adoption: The likes of Tesla have brought EVs into the limelight, making them not just a sustainable choice, but also a trendy one.

Hydrogen Fuel Cell Vehicles

  • Niche markets: One area where FCVs might lead is in sectors where longer ranges and quick refuelling times are paramount. Think long-haul trucks, buses, and certain commercial vehicles.
  • Green hydrogen: The future of FCVs is closely tied to the production of ‘green’ hydrogen derived from renewable sources. If technological and economic barriers are overcome, and green hydrogen becomes mainstream, FCVs could experience a renaissance.
  • Infrastructure development: The creation of a robust hydrogen refuelling infrastructure could be a game-changer. While it currently lags behind EV charging stations, focused investments and strategic partnerships might boost its growth.

If you’re considering investing in a FCV or EV and want to scrap your existing car, Assington Autos is here to help. We offer approved car scrappage covering Essex and the surrounding areas. Contact us today to arrange a pick-up of your scrap car.